IRJET-PERFORMANCE ANALYSIS OF NUTRIENT REMOVAL IN POND WATER USING WATER HYACINTH AND AZOLLA WITH PAPAYA STEM
Content
International Research Journal of Engineering and Technology (IRJET)
Volume: 02 Issue: 01 | Apr-2015
www.irjet.net
e-ISSN: 2395 -0056
p-ISSN: 2395-0072
PERFORMANCE ANALYSIS OF NUTRIENT REMOVAL IN POND WATER
1.INTRODUCTION :USING WATER HYACINTH AND AZOLLA
WITH PAPAYA STEM
Human population increase and rapid industrialization
2
Anandha Varun R 1over
, Kalpana
the pastScentury have resulted great after effects to
1 PG
the environment.Particularly water consumption have
Student,Department of Civil Engineering,Dr.M.G.R Educational
and Research Institute University,Chennai
become more high than the past century.Increased
consumption of water led to increase in sewage.Increase
in sewage means increase in trouble for the
environment.When the sewage goes beyond controllable
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------level it could possess a major threat to the environment
ABSTRACT – Depletion of water bodies such as lakes
and a problem for the human society. Improper
ponds and rivers are taking place in a faster rate due to
management of sewage could possess a vulnerable threat
increase in population. Excess of domestic sewage
to soil and water table by creating a irreversible damage.
water is let into local water bodies without proper
Excess of nutrients in sewage could be a problem for local
pretreatment. Domestic sewage water when mixed
water bodies that have become dumpsites for local
with surface water can lead to increase in nutrient
sewage.
content of the water .Eutrophification can lead to algal
2
Assistant Professor,Department of Civil Engineering,Dr.M.G.R Educational and Research Institute versity,Chennai
blooms, increase in turbidity, low dissolved oxygen and
decrease in species diversity.The main objective of this
project is determine the nutrient removal efficiency of
papaya stem with Water hyacinth and Azolla.In this
method, performance of Eichhornia sp.,Azolla sp. and
papaya stem was used to find their nutrient removal in
batch mode for 24 days time period in pond water and
samples are collected ever four days interval over the
time period.About 100g of each plant and 100g of
papaya stem for each reactor was used for the
treatment of pond water. Various nutrients such as
ammonia,nitrate and phosphate were analysed
throughtout the study.Water hyacinth with papaya
stem showed greater removal of nitrate (74%) and
ammonia(67%).Azolla with papaya stem showed a
greater removal in phosphate(80%).From the study
water hyacinth with papaya showed a better
performance than azolla and papaya stem.Further
pretreatment of papaya stem ,increase in size of the
reactor and amount of papaya stem used could be
improved for better performance of the waste water
treatment. This experiment will have more scope by
conducting it at a larger scale to get efficiency of the
materials used.
Keywords : Nutrient removal, Water yacinth,Azolla,Papaya
stem ,Pond water.
© 2015, IRJET.NET- All Rights Reserved
Eutrophication is the general term used for describing the
process where water bodies receive excess nutrients that
could stimulate the plant or algae growth.Eutrophication
is mainly caused due to the run off due to rain,farms
which uses inorganic fertiliser,soil erosion, discharge of
detergents containing phosphates, discharging of partially
treated or untreated sewage.
It may result in increase in turbidity,plant and animal
biomass increase, sedimentation rate increase there by
reducing the lifespan of the lake,species diversity
decreases. The most notable effect in eutrophication is
algal blooms. When a bloom occurs, water body is covered
with algae,which is usually bright green which blocks the
light from reaching the surface of the water.This reduces
the photosynthesizing of plants, which decrease the
oxygen content of the water.If the bloom increases due to
excess sewage it would cause organisms to die. When the
oxygen in water becomes too low,this stage is called
hypoxic.If hypoxia increases, no life would survive and a
dead zone is created. Finally whole environment would be
devasted.
Water hyacinth has accumulated a large amount of
nitrogen and phosphorus without any anatomical changes
in one year phytoremediation process[1].Water hyacinth
is used to treat waste water from dairies, tanneries, sugar
factories, pulp and paper industries, palm oil mills,
Page 444
International Research Journal of Engineering and Technology (IRJET)
Volume: 02 Issue: 01 | Apr-2015
www.irjet.net
e-ISSN: 2395 -0056
p-ISSN: 2395-0072
distilleries, etc. The water hyacinth have been found to
have potential for use as phytoremediation, paper, organic
fertilizer, biogas production, human food, fiber, animal
fodder[2].
duration of 1week.And about 100g of the plant was used
for experimental use. Water hyacinth was selected due its
adaptability to the environment and for its overall
performance.
Excess nitrate concentrations in aquatic systems, the
primary source are surface runoff from agricultural or
landscaped areas which have received excess nitrate
fertilizer. Consequently, as nitrates form a component of
total dissolved solids, they are widely used as an indicator
of water quality[3].
Azolla microphylla commonly known as Azolla is a free
floating aquatic fern.It grows from 1 to 2.5cm wide and is
bright green colour.It changes to deep red when it is
exposed to sun .When there is excess nutrients ,profilic
growth will be a problem for waterways. It can grow at an
optimum temperature of 30C.
Phosphorus can stimulate growth of algae and other
organisms. Because of noxious algal blooms that occur in
surface water, there is presently much interest in
controlling the amount of phosphorus compounds that
enters surface waters via domestic and industrial waste
discharges and natural runoff [4].
Azolla was collected from Agricultural College, Madurai
where it was grown as a fertilizer in ponds. About 400g
was collected and brought in a plastic container and
moved to another tank for acclimatization for a duration
of 1 week. After a week 100g of azolla was weighed and
used for experimental purpose.
Phytoaccumulation potential of macrophytes with
emphasis on utilization of Azolla as a promising candidate
for phytoremediation. The ability to hyperaccumulate
heavy metals makes them interesting research candidates,
especially for the treatment of industrial effluents and
sewage waste water[6].
After the acclimatization for a time of about 1 week the
plants are removed from the control tank and the weighed
for about 100grams each.
Azolla,Water hyacinth performed well in sewage effluent
better than Pistia by showing a greater reduction in
nutrient removal over a period of 10days in sewage
treatment plant effluent under laboratory conditions[8].
2. MATERIALS AND METHODS:
Eichhornia crassipes commonly known as Water hyacinth
is a free floating perennial plant that has dark green leaves
as fan shaped are attached to a spongy,inflated petiole.It’s
roots lie beneath the water which is thick,heavily
branched,dark fibrous root system.The water hyacinth is a
fast growing plant and can cover a very large area of water
in a very less time period.Its optimum temperature for
growth is 25-30C.
Water hyacinth was collected from a local stream and it
was carefully cleaned for dirt and debris attached to the
root and the water hyacinth was allowed to grow in
continer under lab conditions for acclimatization for a
© 2015, IRJET.NET- All Rights Reserved
Carica Papaya which is commonly known as Papaya which
is extensively cultivated throughout the world. Papaya is a
tropical fruit obtained from papaya tree like plant growing
to a height of 5-10m.Papaya stem is strong due to rich
fibre and water content but of no use. Generally it is
considered as agricultural waste and often occupies
landfill once the field is cleared.
Papaya stem was obtained from the local farm and then
cut into sticks of required sizes and then the cortex region
is alone left and pith region is removed .The cleaned stem
is allowed to sun dry to obtain a filter like material .This
sun dry is for a period of about 1 month in which the stem
dries there by the water content of the stem is reduced to
a greater extent. Then the dried stem is cleaned for any
foreign particles and then weighed.About 100g of dried
stem is taken for the each reactor.
Waste water was collected from Thiruparankundram
pond where the sewage of the area is dumped mostly.Due
excess sewage let into the pond the nutrient content
increases drastically to provide a suitable environment for
Page 445
International Research Journal of Engineering and Technology (IRJET)
Volume: 02 Issue: 01 | Apr-2015
www.irjet.net
algal blooms and other species over grow thus affecting
the ecosystem.
e-ISSN: 2395 -0056
p-ISSN: 2395-0072
Characteristics
Permissible
Limit
Obtained
pH
5.5 – 9.0
8.1
TSS
100 mg/L
760 mg/L
Temperature
-
24C
BOD
30
72 mg/L
COD
250
166 mg/L
Phosphate (PO4)
5
5.2 mg/L
Nitrate(NO3)
10
12.4 mg/L
Ammonia(NH3)
5
7.6 mg/L
2.1 Experimental Setup
About 35 litres of waste water was collected in plastic
containers from the pond at the mixing point of sewage.
The experiement was conducted with three rectangular
glass reactors(0.4m length x 0.18m width x 0.2m height)
with a working depth of 0.14m each, a surface area of
0.37m2 and a capacity of 10L.Three reactors are R1-Water
hyacinth with papaya stem,R2-Azolla with papaya
stem,R3-Papaya stem alone. Initially the weighed papaya
stem of about 100g is submerged into each reactor and
100g of water hyacinth is added to R1 and 100g of azolla
is added to R2.And R3 is left alone with the papaya
stem.About 30% of reactor height is provided with papaya
stem .A tube of about 1cm dia and 25cm length is fitted to
the left side of all reactors. A small pipe of about 0.5cm dia
and 6cm long is attached to the right side of the all
reactors at 9cm from bottom and one end and a stopper is
provided at the end .The permissible limit was obtained
from General standards for discharge of environmental
pollutants Part-A : Effluents,Schedule-VI,The Environment
Protection Rules,1986[7].Nutrient content was analysed
over a time period of about every four days after the initial
test has been made.
Table-1: Initial analysis of water sample
After the initial analysis,about 500ml of waste water from
each reactor is collected regularly at an interval of 4 days
upto 24 days for nutrient variation of the time period.
Removal efficiency was calculated using the formulae:-
2.2 Estimation of Initial Parameters of the Waste
water:
Major parameters such as p,TSS, Temperature,
BOD,COD,Phosphate,Nitrate,Ammonia were analysed and
tabulated in [5].
Then initial analysis for various parameter have been
tabulated in Table. 1
© 2015, IRJET.NET- All Rights Reserved
Efficiency = Initial – Final x 100%
Final
3. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION:3.1. Nitrate Removal
The initial level of nitrate in the waste water is about
12.4mg/l which is much higher than the permissible level
10mg/L for a inland surface water.During the time period
of over 24 days R1 reduced nitrate to a effective level
3.2mg/L of about 74%,this shows water hyacinth with
papaya stem reduces nitrate to a greater extent in Fig(
).R2 with azolla and papaya stem showed a nominal level
in reducing nitrate to 5.3mg/L of about 57%.R3 with
Page 446
International Research Journal of Engineering and Technology (IRJET)
Volume: 02 Issue: 01 | Apr-2015
www.irjet.net
papaya stem alone performed average of 8.3mg/L about
33%,since no pretreatment was provided to the stem.
Nitrate removal
10
3.3 Phosphate Removal
Phosphate was found to be 5.2mg/L which is slightly
above the acceptable level of 5.0mg/L.During the 24 days
removal of phosphate was found to be reduced greatly by
R2 with azolla and papaya stem to 1.0mg/L about 80%.R1
also performed well but it followed R2,the removal of
phosphate to 1.5mg/L in R1 is about 71%.R2 showed a
constant reduction in phosphate which Fig. .R3 showed a
moderate reduction in phosphate 4.1mg/L of about 21%.
R3
Phosphate Removal
6
mg/L
24 days
20 days
16 days
R2
12 days
0
8 days
R1
4 days
5
Initial
mg/L
15
e-ISSN: 2395 -0056
p-ISSN: 2395-0072
Graph 1 : Nitrate reduction over 24 days
4
2
0
R1
R2
R3
3.2. Ammonia Removal
The initial amount of ammonia obtained was about
7.6mg/L which is much greater than the permissible limit
of 5.0mg/L.Due to the presence of plants R1 and R2 with
papaya stem decreased ammonia to 2.5mg/L (67%) and
2.9mg/L (62%) where as the R3 with papaya stem alone
showed a average performance of about 5.4mg/L
(29%).During the first 12 days ammonia reduction was to
active and then it started to reduce. Reduction of ammonia
is tabulated in
mg/L
Ammonia removal
8
6
4
2
0
R1
R2
R3
Graph 2 : Ammonia reduction over 24 days
© 2015, IRJET.NET- All Rights Reserved
Graph 3 : Phosphate reduction over 24 days
CONCLUSION:
Domestic sewage consists of enormous quality of
nutrients such as nitrate, ammonia and phosphates.
Nutrients in such large quantites may affect the ecological
balance of the environment. These nutrients should used
properly or treated effectively before they are let into the
water bodies. These nutrients might induce the growth of
certain species of algae and other organisms in particular
leading to a imbalanced ecosystem of water body.
Therefore it becomes necessary to reduce the amount of
nutrients in the water. Nutrient removal was achieved to a
certain level with the help of water hyacinth,azolla and
papaya stem. Water hyacinth with papaya stem effectively
reduced ammonia (67%) and nitrate (74%) well below
the permissible level.Azolla with papaya stem reduced
phosphate (80%) to a considerable amount. Papaya stem
showed an average performance throughout the entire
process of reduction where as water hyacinth and azolla
with papaya showed a greater reduction due to the
natural uptake of nutrients for the plant growth which
Page 447
International Research Journal of Engineering and Technology (IRJET)
Volume: 02 Issue: 01 | Apr-2015
www.irjet.net
showed greater removal than papaya stem alone. Further
improvements can be achieved by change in reactor size
and amount of papaya stem used .The reduction of
nutrients from wastewater with water hyacinth and
papaya stem achieved is acceptable.
REFERENCES:
[1] Alireza Valipour,Venkatraman Kalyan Raman and
Young-Ho Ahn, Effectiveness of Domestic
Wastewater Treatment Using a Bio-Hedge Water
Hyacinth Wetland System , Water 2015, 7, 329347;
[2] N JAFARI
,Ecological and socio-economic
utilization of water hyacinth (Eichhornia
crassipesMart Solms) J. Appl. Sci. Environ.
Manage. June2010, Vol. 14 (2) 43 – 49
[3] Black A.P and Babers F.H (1939). “Methyl
Nitrate”. Journal of Org Synthetic. Vol 2: Page 412.
[4] Freddy K.R and De Busk W.F, (1985). “Nutrient
removal
Potential
of
Selected
Aquatic
Macrophytes 4”. Journal of Environmental
Quality. Page 459 - 462.
[5] APHA, 1995. Standard method for examination of
pp: 124-154.water and waste water (15 Edition).
APHA, AWWA, Washington D.C.
e-ISSN: 2395 -0056
p-ISSN: 2395-0072
BIBLOGRAPHIES
R.Anandha Varun, PG
Student.M.Tech.,Environmental
Engineering,Dr.M.G.R Educational
and Research Institute
University,Chennai,Tamil Nadu
S.KALPANA ,Assistant Professor, Department of Civil
Engineering, Dr M.G.R Educational and Research Institute
University, Chennai,Tamil Nadu,India.
[6] Sood A, Uniyal PL, Prasanna R, Ahluwalia
AS..Phytoremediation potential of aquatic
macrophyte, Azolla. Ambio. 2012 Mar;41(2):12237.
[7] CPCB, General standards for discharge of
environmental
pollutants
Part-A
:
Effluents,Schedule-VI,The
Environment
Protection Rules,1986.
[8] A.A.Deshmukh
,N.N.
Bandela,
J.R.Chavan
,P.M.Nalawade., Studies on Potential Use of Water
Hyacinth,
Pistia
and
Azolla
for Municipal Waste Water Treatment Vol.3 Nov
2013
© 2015, IRJET.NET- All Rights Reserved
Page 448
Volume: 02 Issue: 01 | Apr-2015
www.irjet.net
e-ISSN: 2395 -0056
p-ISSN: 2395-0072
PERFORMANCE ANALYSIS OF NUTRIENT REMOVAL IN POND WATER
1.INTRODUCTION :USING WATER HYACINTH AND AZOLLA
WITH PAPAYA STEM
Human population increase and rapid industrialization
2
Anandha Varun R 1over
, Kalpana
the pastScentury have resulted great after effects to
1 PG
the environment.Particularly water consumption have
Student,Department of Civil Engineering,Dr.M.G.R Educational
and Research Institute University,Chennai
become more high than the past century.Increased
consumption of water led to increase in sewage.Increase
in sewage means increase in trouble for the
environment.When the sewage goes beyond controllable
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------level it could possess a major threat to the environment
ABSTRACT – Depletion of water bodies such as lakes
and a problem for the human society. Improper
ponds and rivers are taking place in a faster rate due to
management of sewage could possess a vulnerable threat
increase in population. Excess of domestic sewage
to soil and water table by creating a irreversible damage.
water is let into local water bodies without proper
Excess of nutrients in sewage could be a problem for local
pretreatment. Domestic sewage water when mixed
water bodies that have become dumpsites for local
with surface water can lead to increase in nutrient
sewage.
content of the water .Eutrophification can lead to algal
2
Assistant Professor,Department of Civil Engineering,Dr.M.G.R Educational and Research Institute versity,Chennai
blooms, increase in turbidity, low dissolved oxygen and
decrease in species diversity.The main objective of this
project is determine the nutrient removal efficiency of
papaya stem with Water hyacinth and Azolla.In this
method, performance of Eichhornia sp.,Azolla sp. and
papaya stem was used to find their nutrient removal in
batch mode for 24 days time period in pond water and
samples are collected ever four days interval over the
time period.About 100g of each plant and 100g of
papaya stem for each reactor was used for the
treatment of pond water. Various nutrients such as
ammonia,nitrate and phosphate were analysed
throughtout the study.Water hyacinth with papaya
stem showed greater removal of nitrate (74%) and
ammonia(67%).Azolla with papaya stem showed a
greater removal in phosphate(80%).From the study
water hyacinth with papaya showed a better
performance than azolla and papaya stem.Further
pretreatment of papaya stem ,increase in size of the
reactor and amount of papaya stem used could be
improved for better performance of the waste water
treatment. This experiment will have more scope by
conducting it at a larger scale to get efficiency of the
materials used.
Keywords : Nutrient removal, Water yacinth,Azolla,Papaya
stem ,Pond water.
© 2015, IRJET.NET- All Rights Reserved
Eutrophication is the general term used for describing the
process where water bodies receive excess nutrients that
could stimulate the plant or algae growth.Eutrophication
is mainly caused due to the run off due to rain,farms
which uses inorganic fertiliser,soil erosion, discharge of
detergents containing phosphates, discharging of partially
treated or untreated sewage.
It may result in increase in turbidity,plant and animal
biomass increase, sedimentation rate increase there by
reducing the lifespan of the lake,species diversity
decreases. The most notable effect in eutrophication is
algal blooms. When a bloom occurs, water body is covered
with algae,which is usually bright green which blocks the
light from reaching the surface of the water.This reduces
the photosynthesizing of plants, which decrease the
oxygen content of the water.If the bloom increases due to
excess sewage it would cause organisms to die. When the
oxygen in water becomes too low,this stage is called
hypoxic.If hypoxia increases, no life would survive and a
dead zone is created. Finally whole environment would be
devasted.
Water hyacinth has accumulated a large amount of
nitrogen and phosphorus without any anatomical changes
in one year phytoremediation process[1].Water hyacinth
is used to treat waste water from dairies, tanneries, sugar
factories, pulp and paper industries, palm oil mills,
Page 444
International Research Journal of Engineering and Technology (IRJET)
Volume: 02 Issue: 01 | Apr-2015
www.irjet.net
e-ISSN: 2395 -0056
p-ISSN: 2395-0072
distilleries, etc. The water hyacinth have been found to
have potential for use as phytoremediation, paper, organic
fertilizer, biogas production, human food, fiber, animal
fodder[2].
duration of 1week.And about 100g of the plant was used
for experimental use. Water hyacinth was selected due its
adaptability to the environment and for its overall
performance.
Excess nitrate concentrations in aquatic systems, the
primary source are surface runoff from agricultural or
landscaped areas which have received excess nitrate
fertilizer. Consequently, as nitrates form a component of
total dissolved solids, they are widely used as an indicator
of water quality[3].
Azolla microphylla commonly known as Azolla is a free
floating aquatic fern.It grows from 1 to 2.5cm wide and is
bright green colour.It changes to deep red when it is
exposed to sun .When there is excess nutrients ,profilic
growth will be a problem for waterways. It can grow at an
optimum temperature of 30C.
Phosphorus can stimulate growth of algae and other
organisms. Because of noxious algal blooms that occur in
surface water, there is presently much interest in
controlling the amount of phosphorus compounds that
enters surface waters via domestic and industrial waste
discharges and natural runoff [4].
Azolla was collected from Agricultural College, Madurai
where it was grown as a fertilizer in ponds. About 400g
was collected and brought in a plastic container and
moved to another tank for acclimatization for a duration
of 1 week. After a week 100g of azolla was weighed and
used for experimental purpose.
Phytoaccumulation potential of macrophytes with
emphasis on utilization of Azolla as a promising candidate
for phytoremediation. The ability to hyperaccumulate
heavy metals makes them interesting research candidates,
especially for the treatment of industrial effluents and
sewage waste water[6].
After the acclimatization for a time of about 1 week the
plants are removed from the control tank and the weighed
for about 100grams each.
Azolla,Water hyacinth performed well in sewage effluent
better than Pistia by showing a greater reduction in
nutrient removal over a period of 10days in sewage
treatment plant effluent under laboratory conditions[8].
2. MATERIALS AND METHODS:
Eichhornia crassipes commonly known as Water hyacinth
is a free floating perennial plant that has dark green leaves
as fan shaped are attached to a spongy,inflated petiole.It’s
roots lie beneath the water which is thick,heavily
branched,dark fibrous root system.The water hyacinth is a
fast growing plant and can cover a very large area of water
in a very less time period.Its optimum temperature for
growth is 25-30C.
Water hyacinth was collected from a local stream and it
was carefully cleaned for dirt and debris attached to the
root and the water hyacinth was allowed to grow in
continer under lab conditions for acclimatization for a
© 2015, IRJET.NET- All Rights Reserved
Carica Papaya which is commonly known as Papaya which
is extensively cultivated throughout the world. Papaya is a
tropical fruit obtained from papaya tree like plant growing
to a height of 5-10m.Papaya stem is strong due to rich
fibre and water content but of no use. Generally it is
considered as agricultural waste and often occupies
landfill once the field is cleared.
Papaya stem was obtained from the local farm and then
cut into sticks of required sizes and then the cortex region
is alone left and pith region is removed .The cleaned stem
is allowed to sun dry to obtain a filter like material .This
sun dry is for a period of about 1 month in which the stem
dries there by the water content of the stem is reduced to
a greater extent. Then the dried stem is cleaned for any
foreign particles and then weighed.About 100g of dried
stem is taken for the each reactor.
Waste water was collected from Thiruparankundram
pond where the sewage of the area is dumped mostly.Due
excess sewage let into the pond the nutrient content
increases drastically to provide a suitable environment for
Page 445
International Research Journal of Engineering and Technology (IRJET)
Volume: 02 Issue: 01 | Apr-2015
www.irjet.net
algal blooms and other species over grow thus affecting
the ecosystem.
e-ISSN: 2395 -0056
p-ISSN: 2395-0072
Characteristics
Permissible
Limit
Obtained
pH
5.5 – 9.0
8.1
TSS
100 mg/L
760 mg/L
Temperature
-
24C
BOD
30
72 mg/L
COD
250
166 mg/L
Phosphate (PO4)
5
5.2 mg/L
Nitrate(NO3)
10
12.4 mg/L
Ammonia(NH3)
5
7.6 mg/L
2.1 Experimental Setup
About 35 litres of waste water was collected in plastic
containers from the pond at the mixing point of sewage.
The experiement was conducted with three rectangular
glass reactors(0.4m length x 0.18m width x 0.2m height)
with a working depth of 0.14m each, a surface area of
0.37m2 and a capacity of 10L.Three reactors are R1-Water
hyacinth with papaya stem,R2-Azolla with papaya
stem,R3-Papaya stem alone. Initially the weighed papaya
stem of about 100g is submerged into each reactor and
100g of water hyacinth is added to R1 and 100g of azolla
is added to R2.And R3 is left alone with the papaya
stem.About 30% of reactor height is provided with papaya
stem .A tube of about 1cm dia and 25cm length is fitted to
the left side of all reactors. A small pipe of about 0.5cm dia
and 6cm long is attached to the right side of the all
reactors at 9cm from bottom and one end and a stopper is
provided at the end .The permissible limit was obtained
from General standards for discharge of environmental
pollutants Part-A : Effluents,Schedule-VI,The Environment
Protection Rules,1986[7].Nutrient content was analysed
over a time period of about every four days after the initial
test has been made.
Table-1: Initial analysis of water sample
After the initial analysis,about 500ml of waste water from
each reactor is collected regularly at an interval of 4 days
upto 24 days for nutrient variation of the time period.
Removal efficiency was calculated using the formulae:-
2.2 Estimation of Initial Parameters of the Waste
water:
Major parameters such as p,TSS, Temperature,
BOD,COD,Phosphate,Nitrate,Ammonia were analysed and
tabulated in [5].
Then initial analysis for various parameter have been
tabulated in Table. 1
© 2015, IRJET.NET- All Rights Reserved
Efficiency = Initial – Final x 100%
Final
3. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION:3.1. Nitrate Removal
The initial level of nitrate in the waste water is about
12.4mg/l which is much higher than the permissible level
10mg/L for a inland surface water.During the time period
of over 24 days R1 reduced nitrate to a effective level
3.2mg/L of about 74%,this shows water hyacinth with
papaya stem reduces nitrate to a greater extent in Fig(
).R2 with azolla and papaya stem showed a nominal level
in reducing nitrate to 5.3mg/L of about 57%.R3 with
Page 446
International Research Journal of Engineering and Technology (IRJET)
Volume: 02 Issue: 01 | Apr-2015
www.irjet.net
papaya stem alone performed average of 8.3mg/L about
33%,since no pretreatment was provided to the stem.
Nitrate removal
10
3.3 Phosphate Removal
Phosphate was found to be 5.2mg/L which is slightly
above the acceptable level of 5.0mg/L.During the 24 days
removal of phosphate was found to be reduced greatly by
R2 with azolla and papaya stem to 1.0mg/L about 80%.R1
also performed well but it followed R2,the removal of
phosphate to 1.5mg/L in R1 is about 71%.R2 showed a
constant reduction in phosphate which Fig. .R3 showed a
moderate reduction in phosphate 4.1mg/L of about 21%.
R3
Phosphate Removal
6
mg/L
24 days
20 days
16 days
R2
12 days
0
8 days
R1
4 days
5
Initial
mg/L
15
e-ISSN: 2395 -0056
p-ISSN: 2395-0072
Graph 1 : Nitrate reduction over 24 days
4
2
0
R1
R2
R3
3.2. Ammonia Removal
The initial amount of ammonia obtained was about
7.6mg/L which is much greater than the permissible limit
of 5.0mg/L.Due to the presence of plants R1 and R2 with
papaya stem decreased ammonia to 2.5mg/L (67%) and
2.9mg/L (62%) where as the R3 with papaya stem alone
showed a average performance of about 5.4mg/L
(29%).During the first 12 days ammonia reduction was to
active and then it started to reduce. Reduction of ammonia
is tabulated in
mg/L
Ammonia removal
8
6
4
2
0
R1
R2
R3
Graph 2 : Ammonia reduction over 24 days
© 2015, IRJET.NET- All Rights Reserved
Graph 3 : Phosphate reduction over 24 days
CONCLUSION:
Domestic sewage consists of enormous quality of
nutrients such as nitrate, ammonia and phosphates.
Nutrients in such large quantites may affect the ecological
balance of the environment. These nutrients should used
properly or treated effectively before they are let into the
water bodies. These nutrients might induce the growth of
certain species of algae and other organisms in particular
leading to a imbalanced ecosystem of water body.
Therefore it becomes necessary to reduce the amount of
nutrients in the water. Nutrient removal was achieved to a
certain level with the help of water hyacinth,azolla and
papaya stem. Water hyacinth with papaya stem effectively
reduced ammonia (67%) and nitrate (74%) well below
the permissible level.Azolla with papaya stem reduced
phosphate (80%) to a considerable amount. Papaya stem
showed an average performance throughout the entire
process of reduction where as water hyacinth and azolla
with papaya showed a greater reduction due to the
natural uptake of nutrients for the plant growth which
Page 447
International Research Journal of Engineering and Technology (IRJET)
Volume: 02 Issue: 01 | Apr-2015
www.irjet.net
showed greater removal than papaya stem alone. Further
improvements can be achieved by change in reactor size
and amount of papaya stem used .The reduction of
nutrients from wastewater with water hyacinth and
papaya stem achieved is acceptable.
REFERENCES:
[1] Alireza Valipour,Venkatraman Kalyan Raman and
Young-Ho Ahn, Effectiveness of Domestic
Wastewater Treatment Using a Bio-Hedge Water
Hyacinth Wetland System , Water 2015, 7, 329347;
[2] N JAFARI
,Ecological and socio-economic
utilization of water hyacinth (Eichhornia
crassipesMart Solms) J. Appl. Sci. Environ.
Manage. June2010, Vol. 14 (2) 43 – 49
[3] Black A.P and Babers F.H (1939). “Methyl
Nitrate”. Journal of Org Synthetic. Vol 2: Page 412.
[4] Freddy K.R and De Busk W.F, (1985). “Nutrient
removal
Potential
of
Selected
Aquatic
Macrophytes 4”. Journal of Environmental
Quality. Page 459 - 462.
[5] APHA, 1995. Standard method for examination of
pp: 124-154.water and waste water (15 Edition).
APHA, AWWA, Washington D.C.
e-ISSN: 2395 -0056
p-ISSN: 2395-0072
BIBLOGRAPHIES
R.Anandha Varun, PG
Student.M.Tech.,Environmental
Engineering,Dr.M.G.R Educational
and Research Institute
University,Chennai,Tamil Nadu
S.KALPANA ,Assistant Professor, Department of Civil
Engineering, Dr M.G.R Educational and Research Institute
University, Chennai,Tamil Nadu,India.
[6] Sood A, Uniyal PL, Prasanna R, Ahluwalia
AS..Phytoremediation potential of aquatic
macrophyte, Azolla. Ambio. 2012 Mar;41(2):12237.
[7] CPCB, General standards for discharge of
environmental
pollutants
Part-A
:
Effluents,Schedule-VI,The
Environment
Protection Rules,1986.
[8] A.A.Deshmukh
,N.N.
Bandela,
J.R.Chavan
,P.M.Nalawade., Studies on Potential Use of Water
Hyacinth,
Pistia
and
Azolla
for Municipal Waste Water Treatment Vol.3 Nov
2013
© 2015, IRJET.NET- All Rights Reserved
Page 448
